Spoil and get spoiled about Issue #11

Comments: 42 (Discussion closed)
  • #1

    fxrocks (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 06:57)

    So, please Felix, what happened ? :)

  • #2

    fxrocks (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 07:55)

    ( or anybody else who got the issue )

  • #3

    sarah (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 08:42)

    someone spoil me :)

  • #4

    the power of three (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 10:39)

    what happend and what powers are used?

  • #5

    Megawhatz123 (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 13:16)

    I dont think anyone actually got the presant

  • #6

    Megawhatz123 (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 13:16)

    Sorry i meant issue not presant

  • #7

    Charmedfan2011 (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 14:14)

    Does anyone have any spoilers?

  • #8

    Felix (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 16:03)

    So ...
    -Sam comes to help although he doesn't fo much.
    -Neena combines the upper regions and the underworld so on earth theres thunder.
    -Victor comes to watch the kids (We see all of them)
    -Victor and Henry talk about being married to a witch.
    -Phoebe communicates with her sisters telepathicaly
    -Piper comes home by trusting Cole and biting the apple again.
    -Kyle and Paige go into the light and they end up in the Manor (not the past. Possibly the afterlife) where theres penny and Paty (As ghosts, I think) and for a second you think Prue will show up but no.
    -To get enough power to save the world the whole line of warren/Halliwells are at this manor, including, I think, Melinda Warren.

  • #9

    fxrocks (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 16:26)

    Oww too bad Prue didn't show up :(
    Were the likenesses good ?

  • #10

    fxrocks (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 16:29)

    and what about the photograph of Phoebe, Piper and Prue. Who looked at it ?

  • #11

    Eric (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 16:52)

    first thats stupid that prue didnt show..second i saw that pic and its pretty but y is it there

  • #12

    fxrocks (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 17:03)

    I was asking about who in the comics saw it (Paige with grams and Patty, Phoebe while cleaning the attic) ?

  • #13

    GC (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 17:41)

    What, no Prue, are you kidding me? You have the whole Warren/Halliwell line, and not Prue??????!!!!!!!!

  • #14

    sarah (Tuesday, 21 June 2011 22:48)

    i know henry and victor know what each of them went and are going throw and are the twins still sleeping lol i was hopeing that prue would come but thats ok :) and well i cant wait to get the issure

  • #15

    Felix (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 03:20)

    Victor picks up the photo and the artwork is great. The only 2 peoples liknesses I didn't like where Neena and Pipers

  • #16

    fxrocks (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 03:47)

    Thanks and is "Last Witch Effort" the official title or not ?

  • #17

    Felix (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 04:07)

    Yes. Lest Witch Effort is the title of the comic.

  • #18

    p3nathan (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 05:32)

    this telepathy that Phoebe uses... is it a spell? A similar connection to what the sisters had in 'Sense and Sense Ability' ?

    Also, I'm not suprised Prue wasn't shown. I think they're trying to make it as close to the show as possible... and Shannen Doherty wouldn't have come back. I know it's a comic and they don't need actors, but after not seeing Prue for 5 years even though they could see pretty much every other dead relative they had... seeing Prue now might seem a bit random.

  • #19

    charmedcomicfan (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 05:56)

    i dont think this is the case, i mean we saw people like brittany and tyler coming back.
    I think Paul is probably keeping Prue away for as long as he can so it has more suspense. I wouldnt be surprised if she showed up in #12 as a surprise especially after it is told in issue #11 that she cant join them

  • #20

    the power of three (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 06:23)

    it is amazing that so much characters have returned!i was hoping that that we will see prue but.... what powers are used? i think phoebe communicate with her sisters like in sense and Sense Ability or with spell if had telepathy she wouldnt used candles...

  • #21

    the power of three (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 06:55)

    @charmedcomicfan you will upload the pictures and history in the profiles,species and powers today? i like that we see victor,patty,penny,sam,the kids and the all the warren witches!phoebe used a spell or used the power of htreee to communicate???

  • #22

    fxrocks (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 06:56)

    @charmedcomicfan you wrote : " I wouldnt be surprised if she showed up in #12 as a surprise especially after it is told in issue #11 that she cant join them ". If it is told that she cant join them, it would actually be a suprise, no? and who/what told that ?

  • #23

    GC (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 10:21)

    Why can't Prue join them?

  • #24

    JoshingAbout (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 11:48)

    Patty and Grams tell Paige that Prue won't be there to help them.

    Paige: "But Prue? Will I finally get to meet my sister?"
    Patty: "That's a little more complicated. She won't be able to join us for this."
    Paige: "But we could use her strength. We're going to need everything we've got to reclaim the Upper Regions."
    Grams: "We're sorry, Paige. It has to be that way."
    Patty: "But we're still pretty powerful without her."
    Kyle: "I think you'll be impressed with what your mother and Grams have managed to pull together."

    [Downstairs in the Afterlife of the Manor is full of past Warren Witches.]
    Melina Warren: Blessed be, Paige. Blessed be.

    I have a feeling that Prue will make an appearence in Issue #12 simply because she can't take part in whatever Patty and Grams have planned. Also, back when Marcio Abreu was the artist for the comics, he did a sketch of Prue with the likeness of Shannon Doherty... I think Ruditis has a huge appearence planned, and Paige's venture into the Afterlife seems to be a great way of having Prue reappear. I'm really hoping =D

    It was a great issue, and I was sad that it ended as I wanted to keep on reading!

  • #25

    the power of three (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 11:52)

    @JoshingAbout i hope too that prue will make an appearence in issue 12!can you tell me what power are used?

  • #26

    fxrocks (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 11:58)

    I hope that she will be in issue 12 too but I don't know why I think she won't :(

  • #27

    JoshingAbout (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 12:38)

    I made a typo error in my last post, that's meant to be Melinda Warren*

    Hmm, powers...

    * Sam tries to Heal Paige although it's not shown, only mentioned.
    * Piper bites into the apple which conjures a portal home.
    * Kyle and Paige walk into the light, which conjures a portal to the Afterlife.

    That's about it. No active powers were used in this issue. To be honest it didn't need them, as enough was going on. There were a few spells used, however.

  • #28

    the power of three (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 15:25)

    thank you! So paige is alive. Kyle? phoebe used a spell to comunicate with her sisters or a ritual?can anybody add a full synopsis?

  • #29

    GC (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 20:43)

    Grr....Prue better be in issue 12.

  • #30

    GC (Wednesday, 22 June 2011 20:54)

    I just thought of something though. Piper and Phoebe are back together, Paige is in the afterlife. What if Patty meant Prue can't join her, Grams and Paige, because she's helping Piper and Phoebe, thereby bringing back the original Charmed Ones while Paige and the Warren Line liberate the Upper regions...Or am I stretching?

  • #31

    fxrocks (Thursday, 23 June 2011 05:11)

    @GC Oh my god, that would the best explanation to the fact that Prue can't join Paige.

  • #32

    Chuckie (Friday, 24 June 2011 01:01)

    OMG it would be the most amazing thing ever. Prue joining Piper and Phoebe and at the end of the battle have the meeting of Paige and Prue. I think the writers want to make an emotional and quiet scene with Prue and Paige and wouldn be that sweet in the middle of the battle. so im hoping, and im almost positive, Prue will be back before the first arc is over. Well in issue 12 :D LOVE THE COMICS!

  • #33

    JoshingAbout (Saturday, 25 June 2011 12:15)

    @GC - That would be amazing! If Paige and Prue finally met I'd adore the comics even more than I already do.

    I just had a really awesome scene play out in my head:

    Neena uses her powers to knock down Piper and Phoebe so they can't undo her spell on the twin spheres. Rennek tries to use this to his advantage against Leo, fires an arrow at Piper, aiming to destroy Leo emotionally. Before anyone can do anything, we see a hand lash out from off-page and the arrow flies back and vanquishes Rennek. Everyone turns around only to see Prue, standing there looking all baddass.

    If something like that happened I think I'd squeal like a raving, rabid fanboy.

    Another thought just popped into my head:
    On the front cover of Issue #12 we see Paige as the figure-head, holding a sword that is possibly Excalibur, standing against a figure that is most likely Neena. What if the Warren Witches empower Paige with their pieces of The All, in a hope that their entire family magic will be able to equal Neena? It may give her enough power to wield Excalibur without being corrupted, and the added power might help. That would be pretty baddass.

  • #34

    drewfuller (Sunday, 26 June 2011)

    @JoshingAbout it's cool)))

  • #35

    Emma (Wednesday, 29 June 2011 15:09)

    I think it is a complete and total cop out that they did not bring Prue back. I mean honestly, Paige and Kyle walk into the Summerland (Wiccan Afterlife) hand in hand. They see ever other Dead Wiccan relative except for Prue.


    I mean, come on REALLY! How stupid is this?

    I am really disappointed.

    I understand they might have a huge story line for the return of Prue. I get that! Maybe three of four comic stories in... BAM! She comes back!

    But if your going to do that, don't insult my high IQ by this half a-zz story about Prue not being able to come? What, was she getting her nails done in the afterlife salon? she is too busy to attend! REALLY!

  • #36

    JoshingAbout (Thursday, 30 June 2011)

    @Emma - you have to understand that there's so far been no confirmation that Zenescope have permission from Shannen Doherty to use her image in the comics (the image in the Sourcebook doesn't count, as it's a promo from Season 2, back when she didn't own her image.)

    It's a double edged sword. They could bring Prue back and not have her look like Shannen, which would cause an uproar (since it's essentially the same as recasting her), or avoid bringing her back as they can't do her justice due to legalities, which still annoys fans. It's a lose-lose situation.

    And besides, issue 12 isn't even OUT yet. There's still a chance that she DOES come back.

  • #37

    kostasagainsttheworld (Thursday, 30 June 2011 05:49)

    guys, we really dont know if zenescope has shannen's permission or not. I mean did we know if they had Julians or Kaleys? No. We cant really know. We must definately not say that Prue will be back or not cause anything can happen

  • #38

    Phoebe1_ (Thursday, 30 June 2011 16:07)

    Relax! We can always make assumptions! ; ) I really hope we get Prue back too. <3

  • #39

    Emma Again (Thursday, 30 June 2011 22:20)

    Hey "JoshingAbout". Read your post, I understand that we don't know if they have permission or not. I agree with you on that, but that was not my point.

    My point was this:

    Paige and Kyle walk through the light to get to the otherside. Only, no Prue. Everyone else.... Grams, Patty, Melinda, Some chicks from the 1600-1900's but sorry no Prue.

    They all live, or come to the Halliwell Manor located in eternal love and light on the other side.... but Prue did not get the R.S.V.P is not here?

    I mean, really? Does that even sound plausible? It is just so stupid! It is a frack'n comic book and they can't come up with better than this?

    A show and comic book that has Dragons, White lighters, Dark Lighters, Time Traveling, Angels, Avatars, Headless horsemen, Floating magic schools in other dimensions and still Prue can't make into the plan?

    It just really bugs me! BUGS ME TO THE VERY CORE. They can't come up with better stuff than that?

    I feel just so let down.

  • #40

    Charmed Like In All Ways (Thursday, 30 June 2011 22:22)

    I agree with Emma. Now that I think of it, it bugs me too!

    How stupid is that?

    12 better not suck! There better be a better explanation.

    They don't do stupid things like this in BUFFY!

  • #41

    p3nathan (Tuesday, 05 July 2011 08:10)

    OMG will everyone quit bitching about Prue?! It's been over 5 years since they've seen Prue. They can see their mother, they can see their grandmother, they can see Melinda Warren... but not Prue. I have faith that Paul has a good reason for that and if she had just suddenly showed up with all the other relatives in #11, I think it would've been the biggest fail to meet expectations in Charmed history! Have a little faith.

    @ Charmed Like In All Ways... no in Buffy they just turn characters into giants and have Godzilla sized robots! Charmed has been way more realistic so far

  • #42

    GC (Tuesday, 05 July 2011 22:30)

    I was thinking today. This issue is like Forever Charmed. Prue is more then noticeably missing. At least her absence is acknowledged and addressed, although we aren't given a satisfied answer. Better then Forever Charmed where her absence is glossed over. Still, I walk away that same feeling of annoyance...